Lipton’s “Biology of Belief” Debunked: Index of Articles
Part Zero: The Final Summing Up — here’s an opening paragraph:
Sadly, Lipton’s book The Biology of Belief fails entirely, and in the most ridiculous manner, to provide any support for his claims. It is baffling that someone with a Ph.D in biology can get so much basic factual information in his chosen field so wrong. Worse, the way he constructs his argument doesn’t connect up with the case he is trying to make. Unsurprisingly, the result is so incoherent, contradictory, and confusing that even Lipton frequently confuses himself and forgets what his own teachings are, and more than once winds up demolishing the case he was trying to make.
Part 1 The Central Dogma
Part 2 How genes determine life
Part 3 Metaphor and projection
Part 4 Cells seeking comfort
Part 5 Lipton & Lamarck vs Darwin
Part 6 Lipton ascribes Darwin’s ideas to Lamarck
Part 7 Lipton also misses Darwin’s ideas on co-evolution
Part 8 Chapter 1 reviewed
Part 9 Featuring Richard Dawkins on embryology
Part 10 Lipton blows up his own central thesis
Part 11 Lipton’s two distinct styles & punked by Darwin again
Part 12 No, cells don’t have brains or gonads, Dr Lipton!
Part 13 Lipton gets confused about heredity
Part 14 Dr Lipton plays down the danger of cancer, using mice
Part 15 Lipton starts lying
Part 16 Lipton’s own logic demolishes his claim that cells have brains
Part 17 Lipton is an extreme environmental determinist
Part 18 The law of attraction for amoebas
Part 19 Lipton’s theory of evolution
Part 20 Bait and switch with 3 billion distractions
Part 21 Lipton gets another central idea completely wrong
Part 22 Lipton reveals his method, not realising what he’s admitting
Part 23 Lipton thinks the brain is an undifferentiated glob of goo that’s incapable of retaining information
Part 24 The end of Chapter 3
Part 25 Chapter 3 again because of weird and stupid stuff I missed last time
Part 26 Liptonian quantum physics: preliminaries
Part 27 No quantum physics yet
Part 28 The “illusion of matter”
Part 29 Lipton gets confused: is it E=ec2 or E=m (where m= matter) or E=mc, and then squared?
Part 30 The attack on modern medicine begins
Part 31 Liptonian quantum physics in two diagrams
Part 32 Lipton gets confused and promotes Newtonian physics
Part 33 One sentence
Part 34 More quantum physics-free quantum physics
Part 35 Lipton says 3 sensible things in a row!!!!
Part 36 Medicine has not advanced and visible light is invisible
Part 37 Modern medicine and Newtonian gravity
Part 38 Death caused by invisible forces
Part 39 Mammogram of a tumor and Lipton gets his own pseudoscience wrong
Part 40 Vibrators
Part 41 Pseudoscience & cross-promotion
Part 42 Pseudoscience: no progress, just new marketing
Part 43 Lipton tries to present scientific evidence
Part 44 Become a radioasthesiast! Or not….(This is really dumb)
Part 45 Chapter 4 suddenly stops
Part 46 Forgot to write a title for this
Part 47 Lipton gets wrong spiritual ideas wrong
Part 48 Lipton switches laws of physics with laws of grammar
Part 49 Lipton ignores the whole of science
Part 50 Telling your tumor to shrink without flunking
Part 51 The Grand Central Lie (this is really stupid)
Part 52 Lipton states his case and contradicts himself
Part 53 Cartesian dualism unwittingly dropped, picked up, turned into a cartesian trinity
Part 54 Lipton’s model of the brain
Part 55 The gag reflex & the key to Lipton’s quackery
Part 56 Slithering snakes
Part 57 Lipton blows up his own argument yet again
Part 58 Leveraging the placebo effect
Part 59 Lipton unwittingly declares all alternative medicine is just a placebo
Part 60 Lipton’s weird theory of physiology
Part 61 The end of Chapter 6
Part 62 Epigenetic inheritance as a tool for child rearing
Part 63 More confusion about epigenetics
Part 64 Epigenetics and, um, chiropractic?
Part 65 Dr Lipton answers your questions about parenting & blows up his own argument again
Part 66 Dr Lipton advises: throw your baby into a swimming pool
Part 67 Lipton contradicts everything in the entire book
Part 68 Darwinian obstetricians
Part 69 Bruce Lipton doesn’t understand genetics
Part 70 The end, almost
Part 71 The final assault on Darwin
Part 72 Lipton gets evolution wrong, it’s irrelevant to his book, but he attacks Darwin anyway
Part 73 Dr Lipton talks to us about death
Part 74 Reincarnation as a cancer cure
Part 75 Lipton demolishes his own argument yet again
Part 76 Spiritual supremacy & fractal genetics
Part 77 The book stops
Postscript: Part 78 About that man who drank typhoid… (Turns out he was immune!)